When Todd reunites with a childhood friend with a checkered past, he convinces Margaret to represent him in a minor legal case.

Before the big bonfire, Jackie learns about Cole and Alex’s history with another girl. At the party, relationships new and old go up in flames.

At the Homecoming Huddle, Alex and Jackie run the Walter family cider cart together with help from Cole, who struggles to accept life without football.

When the brothers make a bet involving a prank on Jackie, she turns to Katherine but learns that the boys have their own way of handling their issues.